Manchester United vs Paris St Germain 0-2 : Review and Players Ratings.


Just nine days short of the start of the new PL season, Manchester United not only lost against Paris st Germain, but the circumstances of this loss gave place to some wild or predictable rumors about David De Gea, the club’s  number one goalkeeper.


Never before this July 29, 2015, these two clubs had played a friendly game; a win for Laurent Blanc’s squad (with two goals difference) could add more silverware in the Parisian crystal cabinet.This encounter could also be “a dress rehearsal” for the French Champions, just before the Champions Trophy on Saturday August 1, 2015, against Olympique Lyonnais in Montreal.


Even so, the “Red Devils” loss can’t and won’t be put  only on  De Gea’s  doorstep;  both goals were conceded because of his lack of concentration, but he wasn’t the sole responsable.  New signing Bastian Schweinsteiger and Michael  Garrick struggled against the Parisian midfield trio and they obviously needed some help in that central area; early days for newcomer  Memphis Depay too, but he struggled between being quiet and trying to score without force or precision   (2nd, 12th, 36th).

The first goal came  on early: a long ball caused mayhem in Manchester’s defending line ;  who’s more to blame for this lack of concentration(or carelessness), a hesitant De Gea or  Luke’s Shaw catastrophic clearance (under Blaise  Mathuidi’s pressure) beyond his own keeper? (24th)


The second one was even easier; Zlatan Ibrahimovic fed Maxwell a lovely ball passed by Moura and without Darmian nearby, his low cross was met by an inspired Ibrahimovic who just continued his run! A soft goal? Could be, but whose fault ? (36th)

It was a frustrating first half  for United, but Paris had  cleverly taken advantage of some key players poor game; if only Wayne Rooney , Morgan Sneiderlin and Luke Shaw had been more clinical… Nevertheless, the score reflects the better team: Paris’ players  had showed  more energy and mobility than their PL opponents.

Manchester’s boss Louis Van Gaal made several changes after the first half, the most obvious was the subbing of De Gea by Johnstone. PSG’s boss did the same, muscling the team with Edinson Cavani and David Luiz.


After the break, the English team tried to come back and score, but the Parisians held their fortress, efficiently. It was obvious that as the two goals difference could gain them the Trophy, PSG were happy to keep it  going until the end of the game. Alas, despite the ball possession for almost the whole second half, United haven’t done anything with it. Pereira created two half chances for Depay and Juan Mata, but it wasn’t what Van Gaal would like to see.

New Season is around the corner and the “Red Devils” will have a tricky game vs Tottenham Hotspur, at Old Trafford. Louis Van Gall must sort out his goalkeeper situation; should he stay or should he return to his homeland, the time is short for both club and player.



David De Gea: 5  Sam Jonstone : 7,5  Luke Shaw : 6,5  Phil Jones : 7  Daley Blind : 6,5   Matteo Darmian : 6,5  Chris Smalling : 6  Juan Mata: 7  Memphis  Depay: 6  Michael Carrick : 6,5  Asley Young : 7   Jesse Lingard : 6   Andreas Pereira : 7  Bastian Schweinsteiger : 7   Morgan Schneiderlin : 7  Wayne Rooney : 7


Kevin Trapp: 8   Thiago Silva : 7   Yousouf Sabaly : 6,5  David Luiz : 7  Maxwell : 7,5   Marquinos: 6,5   Serge Aurier : 7   Lucas Digne : 7   Gregory van der Wiel : 6,5   David Luiz : 7,5    Marco  Verratti : 7  Adrien  Rabiot:  7   Benjamin Stambouli  : 6,5   Christopher Nkunku : 7  Blaise Matuidi : 8,5 Presnel  Kimpempe : 6   Jean-Kevin Augustin  6,5   Edinson Cavani : 7 Zlatan Ibrahimovic : 9    Lucas : 6,5   Hervin  Ongenda : 6

Here’s the game’s highlights:



Categories: Analysis

Tags: , ,

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: